It's Just Lunch Review: Matchmaking Process, Cost, Safety, and Fit

It’s Just Lunch is a paid matchmaking service built around human matchmakers, curated introductions, and arranged dates rather than public profiles and endless swiping. Its current process page describes an intake, hand-selected matches, date coordination, and post-date feedback. The FAQ says it is fee-based and that pricing depends on the membership package and consultation rather than a public universal rate. That makes the service most relevant to busy professionals who value delegation and privacy, but the higher-touch model is not a guarantee of chemistry, relationship success, or background-screened matches.

Verdict

It’s Just Lunch is a fundamentally different purchase from a dating-app subscription: you are paying for matchmaking labor and arranged introductions. It may suit users who have money but limited time or dislike public profile browsing. It is a poor fit for people who want direct control over a large searchable pool.

Best for and not ideal for

How the matchmaking process works

The current It’s Just Lunch process page describes a six-step model that includes learning about the member, hand-selecting matches, arranging dates, and gathering feedback.

This shifts much of the search workload from the user to the matchmaker.

No public dating profile changes the privacy tradeoff

A private matchmaking model can reduce public exposure compared with an open app profile. You still share personal information with the company and with matches as introductions progress, so review the current privacy terms and only disclose what is relevant.

Use the dating-app privacy checklist as a general framework even though IJL is not a swipe app.

Cost is consultation and package based

The current FAQ says the service is fee-based and pricing varies with the membership package. It does not publish one universal price for everyone.

Before signing, ask for the total package cost, number or type of introductions, term length, refund/cancellation rules, geography, and any additional charges in writing.

What the company guarantees and what it does not

The FAQ says the service guarantees members will go on dates. That is different from guaranteeing a particular number of compatible matches, a second date, exclusivity, or a relationship. Read the contract language carefully.

Background checks

The current FAQ says It’s Just Lunch does not conduct background checks on members. Human matchmaking therefore should not be confused with criminal-history screening.

Use the online-dating safety checklist for first meetings.

Matchmaker feedback can be useful

One advantage of a managed service is the feedback loop after dates. That can help a matchmaker refine future introductions, but the value depends on communication quality and how well the matchmaker understands your real priorities.

Geography matters more than branding

A matchmaking company can have a broad national presence while the practical pool depends on your city, travel range, and selected package. Ask how matches are sourced in your actual area before paying.

Pros

• Human matchmaking and date coordination.
• No need to maintain a public swipe profile.
• Post-date feedback is built into the service model.
• Can reduce time spent browsing and messaging.

Cons

• Fee-based with no single public price.
• Less direct control over the full candidate pool.
• No background checks according to the current FAQ.
• Relationship outcomes cannot be guaranteed.

Alternatives

A mainstream app costs less and gives you more direct control, but requires more screening and messaging. A niche app can narrow the audience without a human matchmaker. The choice is mostly between money, time, privacy, and control.

Use the app-selection guide to make that tradeoff explicit.

Questions to ask before signing

1. What is the total contract price?
2. How long does the membership last?
3. How are potential matches sourced locally?
4. What exactly is guaranteed?
5. What happens if a match is not suitable?
6. What are cancellation/refund terms?
7. Who will be my ongoing matchmaker?

How to compare a matchmaker with a dating app

With an app, you pay mostly for software access and do your own screening. With It’s Just Lunch, a meaningful part of the fee pays for human intake, selection, scheduling, and feedback. The value question is therefore not “How many profiles can I see?” but “How much time and decision work does the matchmaker remove, and are the introductions relevant?”

Ask who counts as a match under the contract

Before signing, clarify whether introductions must meet every stated preference or whether some preferences are treated as flexible. Also ask what happens when you decline an introduction before the date and whether that affects any contractual count or guarantee.

Feedback only helps when it is specific

“No chemistry” gives a matchmaker little to work with. Explain practical patterns such as conversation style, lifestyle mismatch, distance, schedule, attraction, or relationship goals. Good feedback should improve future selection without turning the process into a list of superficial demands.

Watch for sales pressure during consultation

A consultation can be both matchmaking intake and sales conversation. Take enough time to read the contract, total price, refund language, and guarantee terms before committing. Do not let scarcity or a same-day offer replace due diligence on a high-cost service.

Also ask whether matchmaking continues if you travel or relocate during the contract, since geography can materially change the available introduction pool.

Ask how pauses, vacations, or temporary travel affect the membership term as well. A high-touch service is easier to evaluate when timing rules are clear before the contract starts.

FAQ

Is It’s Just Lunch a dating app?

No. It is a matchmaking service centered on human selection and arranged dates.

How much does It’s Just Lunch cost?

The company says pricing varies by package and consultation. Get the current total and contract terms before signing.

Does It’s Just Lunch run background checks?

Its current FAQ says it does not conduct background checks.

Sources and further reading

• It's Just Lunch: Our Process
• It's Just Lunch FAQ

Disclosure: This page contains affiliate links. We may earn a commission without increasing your price. Commercial relationships do not determine our conclusions. Full disclosure.